Review - Young Stalin (Simon Sebag Montefiore)

A generally interesting, readable book that gives an interesting and seemingly well-researched pop history/biography look at Stalin's life before he came to power.

My greatest complaint is that the author seems to lean heavily on stereotypes to characterize the people he talks about--the Svanidze sisters are "Rachvelians from Racha, famous for its placid and loving beauties," the reputation of Georgians in general as being passionate and hotheaded, etc. This is fine, in moderation, and does provide some context for the way many of these people would have been seen in an Imperial Russian and, later, a Soviet context--but these stereotypes are invoked with surprising consistency, sometimes resulting in contradictory descriptions of people and places.

It's enjoyable, and provides a look at Stalin's early biographical context that may not always feature in more conventional accounts of his time in power. Personally I would have favored both a broader and more in-depth treatment of the social, cultural, political, etc. context of the Caucasus in the late 19th and early 20th century (partly just because it's a time period and region of particular interest to me--more interesting to me, personally, than a catalogue of Stalin's affairs), but as the book is a biography of Stalin, it makes sense that it would be focused more exclusively on its own subject.

Comments

Reading Challenges for 2021

I usually do set a numerical goal on the Goodreads reading challenges each year, and find them to be a great way to feel some sense of accomplishment in reading [x] number of books in a given year. Since I also started reviewing some digital ARCs through NetGalley last year, I've been writing more reviews in general (though the non-ARC books I read I may or may not review). I've toyed with the idea of doing some additional challenges before, but haven't--so I'm going to try for it this year! Because this is my first time doing this, I tried to choose challenges that mesh pretty well with what I already tend to read. This means, basically, that they're challenges I could have done okay on with books I read naturally over the course of a year. Yeah, that might not quite be in the "move out of your comfort zone" spirit of many challenges, but it seems like a way to ease into it. So, without further ado, I'm going to be trying the following: Rose City R...

Review - Strange Skies Over East Berlin (Jeff Loveness and Lisandro Estherren)

I really, really wanted to like this graphic novel more than I actually did. It touched on a number of themes I really enjoy in fiction: truth and lies, surveillance and (false) freedom, justice and mercy, idealism and disillusionment, identity and its loss. It featured a morally grey protagonist, and a setting that I tend to enjoy seeing in media. It drew subtle parallels between characters that could have been very poignant and thought-provoking. It had most of the elements that should have made me love it. And yet somehow, it read like a summary of itself. The pacing was too fast to evoke either the poignancy or the quiet horror of which it should have been capable; the art, while evocative and well suited to the story, never felt quite atmospheric enough to capture the suspense and sense of inevitable dread that never quite manifested. For a story that relies so much on the protagonist's sense of himself (or lack thereof) and his lies, I never felt that I knew Her...

Review - American Cider: A Modern Guide to a Historic Beverage

I received an electronic ARC of this book through NetGalley for review. This is a well-written, wide-ranging look at the current state of craft cider production in the United States, divided by region. It does a good job of introducing a variety of topics relevant to both the selection and growing of apples and the process of making those apples into cider, while placing each region's cider into a historical and geographical context. This is really neat, and is pretty well-done. It makes for an enjoyable, educational read. There are times that the historical context overpowers the narrative of cider production. Some parts of the book do sort of read like a high school history textbook (though a markedly readable one), and a reader with a good background in US history that touches on social and agricultural history will likely find much of it review. This isn't necessarily a bad thing--it's absolutely vital context, and important to the book's attempt to d...

Undirected Reading

Search This Blog